We really enjoyed our stay at Roberts place. The apartment had an extremely comfortable/comforting vibe about it and it was also very clean. Very firm mattresses here, which worked for us and a very accommodating host. It certainly doesnt have the most updated of appliances, but honestly, that doesnt matter one bit. I had no problem using anything in this apartment and would definitely recommend others stay here. Great building, nice neighbors, wonderful doormen, outstanding neighborhood (I am a native of ny), tons of grocery stores nearby and steps to the best outdoor run along the hudson river.